Before American Idol, John Foster Was Already a Country Star in the Making And His Joe Diffie Cover Proved It

Before America discovered his rich voice and Southern charm on American Idol, John Foster was already making waves in his hometown of Addis, Louisiana. Long before his Idol debut, the LSU freshman delivered a performance that felt like it came straight out of 1990s country radio — and it’s now resurfacing as proof that this rising star has always been destined for greatness.

A Time Machine to 90s Country

At a sold-out local show, Foster brought the house down with a crowd-pleasing cover of Joe Diffie’s honky-tonk anthem, “Prop Me Up Beside the Jukebox (If I Die).” Every lyric was laced with Foster’s signature charm and authenticity, channeling the energy and swagger that made Diffie a country icon.

His voice rang with the kind of easy confidence that feels both nostalgic and fresh — like flipping through the golden era of country radio with a modern twist.

A Show-Stopping Dual Performance

Just when the audience thought they’d seen it all, Foster stunned the crowd by doing something rarely seen on a small-town stage — he played the guitar and piano simultaneously, layering melodies live with jaw-dropping skill.

The moment wasn’t just a gimmick — it was a bold demonstration of his natural musicality and instinct. And it left the audience speechless.

That one performance became the kind of local legend people would talk about long after the lights went out.

A Hometown Hero in West Baton Rouge

In the neighboring communities of Brusly, Port Allen, and across West Baton Rouge Parish, Foster has long been considered a standout. Known for his manners, talent, and strong values, he’s been winning hearts since middle school.

Christy Fabre, Foster’s former teacher, recalls his early passion for classic country:

“He was always listening to George Strait, Conway Twitty, or Elvis before most kids his age even knew who they were. I always knew John Foster was going to be someone special.”

From running a Bible club at Brusly High School to leading worship at his local church, Foster has always kept one foot rooted in his community and faith.

American Idol & a Tribute That Moved Millions

Now a Top 10 finalist on American Idol Season 23, Foster’s talents have reached national audiences. His powerful performance of “I Told You So” by Randy Travis, dedicated to judge Carrie Underwood, earned him a standing ovation and emotional praise from the panel.

He even tipped his cowboy hat to Carrie at the end — a moment that blended humility, gratitude, and classic country charisma.

But perhaps his most moving moment came with his original song, “Tell That Angel I Love Her,” written in tribute to his late friend Maggie Dunn, who tragically passed away in a car accident.

More Than Music — It’s a Mission

What makes John Foster stand out isn’t just his voice — it’s his integrity, humility, and deep connection to his community. As Fabre puts it:

“He’s a great representative of West Baton Rouge. His charm and kindness are contagious. I hope he inspires more young people to be the Southern gentleman that he is.”

From co-valedictorian to community leader, and now one of American Idol’s brightest stars, Foster’s journey is more than a music career — it’s a love letter to his roots, his family, and the timeless spirit of country music.

And it all began with a Joe Diffie cover, a piano, a guitar — and a whole lot of heart.